The Truth about ScarcityHi Reader, I'm writing this from beautiful Costa Rica, where I've settled in for a few weeks of writing after a fascinating, but exhausting, time at the Author Nation conference in Las Vegas. It was an extraordinary experience, and I learned a tremendous amount about the publishing industry, the future of science fiction and the changes taking place in how books are written and marketed. Unfortunately, I also brought something rather less welcome away from the conference: a chest infection. I've been feeling pretty dreadful for the last few days, but the fever has finally broken, and I'm back at work. One of the highlights of the conference was a talk by Andy Weir, the author of The Martian and Project Hail Mary. There were about 1,500 of us in the audience, and he was enormously entertaining. One story in particular appealed to me because it showed what a lovely sense of humor he has. Apparently, whenever Andy passes through an airport outside his home city, he visits the bookshop, finds copies of his novels, signs them and puts them back on the shelves for unsuspecting customers to discover. I thought that was a wonderful idea. So, as a fellow science fiction author, I've decided to follow his example. From now on, whenever I visit an airport bookshop, I'll look for Andy Weir's books and sign them too. I'm sure he'll appreciate the gesture. There was one other thing about Las Vegas that astonished me, although not in quite such a pleasant way. I was last there in January, and I was shocked by how much prices seemed to have risen since then. I know Las Vegas has always been an expensive city, but $30 for a cheese sandwich and a small bottle of water? I couldn't quite believe it. I have an economics degree, and one of the things that has always fascinated me is how prices reflect scarcity and the allocation of resources. Of course, Las Vegas hotel prices also reflect the fact that they have a captive audience, but it got me thinking about a much bigger question. What if the thing we've feared running out of for centuries is something we haven't even properly started using? When we talk about natural resources, the conversation almost always drifts toward anxiety. We've heard the warnings all our lives: running out of oil, copper becoming harder to find, rare earth elements growing scarce and gold deposits becoming increasingly difficult to exploit. Mining companies are digging deeper, processing lower-grade ores and spending more energy to extract the same quantities of material. Environmental regulations are becoming more demanding, and access to mineral deposits is increasingly influenced by international politics. Greenland is a particularly interesting example. Much of that is true, but only in a rather narrow sense. The easiest deposits have largely been discovered. The shallow, high-grade veins that helped build industrial civilizations are becoming less common, and extracting minerals from the remaining deposits is often more expensive and environmentally damaging. But that doesn't necessarily mean we're running out of metals. Instead, we're running out of convenient geology. Take gold, for example. Humanity has mined roughly 210,000 tonnes throughout its entire history. That sounds like an extraordinary amount, until you realize that all the gold ever mined would fit inside a cube approximately twenty-two meters across, about the length of a tennis court. Considering the size of our planet, that's not exactly an enormous hole in our natural resources. There's more gold dissolved in Earth's oceans, although the concentrations are far too low to make conventional extraction economical. Vast quantities of metals are also locked deep beneath the surface, including in Earth's core, where we have no practical means of reaching them. Copper presents a similar problem. We've mined enormous quantities, but the Earth's crust still contains vastly more. Even rare earth elements, despite their rather alarming name, aren't necessarily rare. The difficulty is finding deposits where they're sufficiently concentrated to extract economically. So the Earth isn't emptying. We're simply reaching the limits of what is currently practical. And this is where things begin to sound rather like science fiction. Our solar system contains an almost unimaginable quantity of mineral resources, particularly in the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter. Some asteroids are rocky, others contain carbon-rich material, and some are dominated by metals. A particularly interesting example is 16 Psyche, an asteroid approximately 220 kilometers across that scientists believe contains substantial quantities of iron and nickel, and possibly gold, silver, platinum and other precious metals. It's possible that some of these metallic asteroids are remnants of the cores of ancient planetary bodies. The amount of material contained in a single large metallic asteroid could exceed everything humanity has ever extracted from Earth. And Psyche is only one of the countless objects scattered throughout the solar system. Suddenly, the familiar story about dwindling resources begins to look rather different. Perhaps we're not a civilization scraping the bottom of an increasingly empty barrel. Perhaps we're standing outside an enormous warehouse, unable to open the door because we haven't yet developed the necessary equipment. Of course, that doesn't mean we can simply fly to an asteroid, load up a few million tonnes of metal and bring it back to Earth. The challenge is enormous. We'd need to transport mining machinery into space, operate it in extremely low gravity, process minerals without conventional industrial infrastructure and decide whether to use the resulting materials in space or transport them back to Earth. That would require advances in robotics, artificial intelligence, propulsion, energy generation and manufacturing. More importantly, it would require the development of a permanent industrial infrastructure beyond our planet. But there's an interesting advantage. Once equipment has reached a small asteroid, moving material away from it requires far less energy than launching the same mass from Earth's surface. There is no substantial gravity well to overcome, and no atmosphere to contend with. Extracting and processing the minerals would still be difficult, but transporting the finished materials around the solar system could eventually become much easier than launching everything from Earth. And that raises a fascinating possibility. What if the scarcity we've always taken for granted is merely a temporary stage in humanity's development? Human civilization has always been shaped by the resources available to it. We talk about the Bronze Age, the Iron Age, the Industrial Revolution and the Information Age because access to new materials, energy sources and technologies changed the way people lived. When resources became difficult to obtain, societies struggled. When new sources became available, entirely new industries emerged. If humanity eventually develops the ability to mine and manufacture in space on an industrial scale, the quantities of raw materials available to us could increase enormously. That doesn't mean everything would suddenly become free. Energy, transportation, skilled labor, technology and manufacturing capacity would still matter, but the physical availability of many minerals might cease to be such a significant constraint. There would also be some interesting economic consequences. Imagine what might happen if someone discovered a way to bring enormous quantities of platinum or gold back to Earth at relatively low cost. The increased supply could drive prices down dramatically, with consequences for mining companies, investors and countries that depend heavily on mineral exports. There would be winners and losers, just as there have been during every major technological revolution. For that reason, I suspect the first truly successful space-mining operations won't involve bringing precious metals back to Earth at all. They'll involve using those materials in space. Imagine constructing enormous space stations, manufacturing spacecraft, building orbital factories and creating habitats without having to launch every component from Earth's surface. Asteroids could provide metals for construction, while water-rich objects, (and there are plenty,) could supply drinking water, oxygen and hydrogen for propellant. Eventually, much of the infrastructure needed to explore and settle the solar system could be manufactured beyond Earth itself. Rather than simply extracting resources to bring home, we'd be expanding the places where humanity could live and work. I find that a tremendously exciting prospect. When I write about fleets crossing interstellar distances or civilizations struggling to survive, I'm often exploring the tension between the limitations we face and the possibilities we haven't yet discovered. In Return to the Galaxy, the Orion Federation survives because its people refuse to accept confinement. They look outward, develop new technologies and find ways to overcome problems that initially seem impossible. There's something profoundly human about that instinct. I grew up in Britain during a period when industrial decline seemed almost permanent. In the early 1980s, unemployment rose dramatically, traditional industries were closing and entire communities felt as though the future had disappeared. Yet within a few decades, computing, the internet, biotechnology and new forms of energy were transforming economies and creating opportunities that would have seemed extraordinary when I was younger. We have a tendency to assume that the problems confronting us today will define our future indefinitely. However, history suggests we should be rather more optimistic about that assumption. Of course, I'm not suggesting that asteroid mining is about to transform the world next year. Serious industrial operations in the asteroid belt remain a long-term prospect, and there are enormous technical and economic obstacles to overcome. We still need to develop much better propulsion systems, reliable autonomous mining machinery and manufacturing facilities capable of operating thousands or millions of miles from Earth. But the underlying opportunity is real. The solar system contains a vast quantity of material that humanity has barely begun to explore, let alone exploit. And perhaps we're still at a very early stage in understanding what that means. We've been an industrial civilization for little more than two centuries, and humans have been traveling into space for only six decades. Judging humanity's long-term future by our present mining capabilities might be rather like judging the future of ocean travel by looking at a man paddling around a lake in a hollowed-out log. Perhaps we're now at the deluxe wooden raft stage. What I find encouraging is that our limitations aren't necessarily permanent. We can develop better technology, discover new sources of energy, build more sophisticated infrastructure and learn how to cooperate on projects that would be impossible for individual nations to undertake alone. There are no guarantees, of course. Greater abundance won't automatically make humanity wiser or more peaceful. We might simply discover new things to argue about, compete over and occasionally fight for. Anyone who has read Return to the Galaxy will know that I don't assume advanced technology automatically produces advanced behavior! But I'd like to believe that opening the resources of the solar system could eventually give humanity more opportunities than we've ever had before. We don't necessarily have to accept a future defined by ever-increasing competition for a shrinking supply of accessible resources. There are alternatives, although reaching them will demand ingenuity, investment and considerable patience. And that brings me to a question I'd genuinely like to hear your thoughts about. If humanity eventually gained access to effectively unlimited raw materials in space, would it make us wiser and more cooperative, or would we simply find new reasons to fight over them? Would abundance reduce conflict, or merely change its nature? Hit reply and tell me what you think. I always enjoy hearing from readers, particularly when your opinions differ from mine. Meanwhile, I'm enjoying Costa Rica enormously. It's a beautiful country, and I've found it a wonderful place to write. Now that my fever has broken, I'm getting back to work on Return to the Galaxy, and I'm looking forward to making further progress over the next few days. Normal service will be resumed next week! Best wishes, Brian ***The Galaxy Faces ExtinctionThe Ranid continue their relentless expansion, but an even greater threat is emerging: the Stillness, an ancient power that once wiped out entire civilisations. As Admiral Ewan Scott searches for answers and Admiral Velal Farn fights to secure new allies, humanity faces its greatest challenge yet. The Ranid believe they cannot be defeated. The Stillness threatens to destroy them all. Humanity intends to defy them both.
***If you've been meaning to dive into the Return to the Galaxy Universe, now’s your chance!Whether you're a new reader or just haven’t grabbed your copies yet, now’s the time to catch up on the award-winning series readers are calling “better than Scalzi” and “the best book since Heinlein died.” If you haven’t started the series yet, Book 1 is still available to buy for 99 cents or read for free on Kindle+:
***Discover More Sci-Fi Adventures Each week, I’ll team up with a group of talented sci-fi authors to bring you an incredible selection of books. Whether you’re looking for thrilling space battles, deep space mysteries, or first-contact encounters, these books are packed with stories to fuel your imagination. Author Spotlight: 12709437 |
I write high-speed, strategy-driven Military Sci-Fi & Space Opera, where cunning commanders, elite soldiers, and alien warlords fight for survival on the fringes of space. Subscribe to my newsletter for my latest updates!
Viva Las Vegas! This week's newsletter is going to be a little different from my usual ones. I'm currently in Las Vegas attending Author Nation, one of the world's largest conferences for independent authors, with more than 1,500 writers from every genre attending. Between the presentations and meeting other writers, I haven't had much time to sit down and write one of my regular articles. It's been a fascinating few days. I've met authors from all sorts of genres, and we've had some very...
Will We Still Need Each Other? (5 minute read) Imagine living in 2076. Your home prepares breakfast, artificial intelligence organizes your day, and robots take care of the cleaning. You can communicate with anybody in the world instantly, in whatever language you prefer, while sophisticated virtual reality allows you to visit distant places without leaving your living room. If you're lonely, your AI companion is always available. It remembers everything you've told it, understands your sense...
What Will Our Cities Look Like in 2076? (5 minute read) fc fImagine walking through New York, London or Singapore in 2076. The buildings are familiar, although many have changed dramatically. Streets that were once crowded with cars now contain trees, gardens and outdoor restaurants. Traffic moves quietly and efficiently, while robots clean the streets, maintain buildings and deliver goods. You might notice something else. There are hardly any parking lots. Cars still exist, but most drive...